I am now submitting to a journal Maternal and Child Health Journal that requires as part of its online process naming three reviewers. It is considered appropriate to indicate what scholars in the field have read the manuscript in order to ensure blind review, correct? Such a summary is especially crucial for highly technical papers, where the chance that the advance may not be fully appreciated by the editors is often higher. A killer cover letter is a must to even get a review by the top science journals. I have never written a cover letter to accompany my submissions. A brief mention of when and where such a conversation occurred can help jog the memory of why we invited the authors to submit it in the first place.
Journal publishing English , Race, Regionalism, and Nationalism. Learn how your comment data is processed. Comments There are currently no comments. Here are some practical tips for potential authors. Featured , General Interest , Journal happenings , Statistics. Thank you very much for this article. Please note that the names of excluded reviewers should also be included in the relevant field of the online submission form.
How to get published… no really, somebody please tell me how Breaking Grad School. And Bjoh was told flat out by both my advisors and journal editors that suggesting specific reviewers is considered unprofessional.
How To Write a Journal Article Submission Cover Letter | The Professor Is In
I want to resubmit the revised version of my paper to proposed journal, but I do not know aughor do I start letter for reviewers? Do put the work in context. Leave a Reply Cancel reply Your email address will not be published. Publishing your first article Tracy Perkins. I am now submitting to a journal Maternal and Child Health Journal that requires as part of its online process naming three reviewers.
Providing context for the paper in a cover letter not only can help the editors reach a quicker decision but also can sometimes tip the balance in favor of sending a borderline paper out for peer review. Learn how your comment data is processed. Especially in more esoteric areas, where experts lettrr few, it is a good idea, because the chance that the article will come their way are relatively high.
How To Write a Journal Article Submission Cover Letter
Assuming there are no instructions, the following is common: I do that, to make sure they are not given the article to read. It then states that the writer is submitting a manuscript for review.
Authors should not hesitate to discuss freely in the cover letter why bbjog believe method is an advance most ideally, backed up with strong performance characteristics in the manuscript! I want to applaud Nature for helping emphasise that sound inference from observation is a cornerstone of science. Previous post How to write a rebuttal letter.
Manuscripts submitted to Nature Methods must first pass an editorial evaluation stage, but as professional editors, we are not experts in every scientific field that the journal covers.
Home About Who is Dr. Articles involved were accepted, so it did not do any harm! But it would be odd to introduce yourself in the way suggested here most lefter do ask for a separate affiliations page, howeveror to suggest reviewers.
It will have proper letter heading material, ie, the date and the address of the recipient at the top left, under the letterhead.
At least, this has been my experience, with 5 articles already in print, all originally submitted as abstracts except one, an invited contribution. Do mention any unusual circumstances. Explaining the advance in a general manner can go a long way in helping the editors reach a quicker decision; cover letters that are largely unreadable are of no help to the editors. Anything else is unprofessional. I published an article as authlr Ph.
A lot of other feedback has made a similar point; this seems to be a a convention that is either field-specific, or one that is in flux, or both. It saves me time working out whether the editorial board are really interested in the article in the first place and as Alessandra says above, means it lrtter go directly to peer-review, having already been approved by the editorial board as an abstract.
The final paragraph will list possible reviewers for the manuscript, and will thank the editor for considering the manuscript for publication. Explain how it relates, and include copies of the related manuscripts with your submission. Wednesday Link Roundup I will put this on my blog too, which I rarely update. I thought everybody did it, but nobody had actually told me to do it, so for a moment there I figured I was fover a brilliant strategist.
No you must not submit an article manuscript to covet than one journal at a time. A brief mention of when and where such a conversation occurred can help jog the memory of why we invited the authors to submit it in the first place.